Human-study video reference

The five study questions

Path match

Does the test fish (right) swim the same route as the real fish (left), including going up or down?

Please ignore differences in body pose (how the body bends or tilts); compare only the route.

very different12345the same

Speed

Can the test fish swim as fast as the real fish?

Note: the simulated fish starts from rest and needs a short time to speed up, while the real fish is already swimming. Please ignore this speed-up and when each fish arrives; judge only its top swimming speed.

much slower12345as fast

Appearance

Does the test fish’s body look like the real fish (shape, size, fins, colour and texture)? Ignore how it moves.

very different12345the same

Overall similarity

Taking everything into account, how similar is the test fish to the real fish?

very different12345the same

Possible for a real fish

How possible is it for a real fish to make this movement?

not possible12345fully possible

Video clips (27)

Real fish on the left; simulated fish on the right. Each method label identifies the right-hand panel.

Lake sturgeon

Window ti2321 · 5 clips

Clip M4BLM + RL
Clip L9CPG + RL
Clip E9Joint RL
Clip D8BCO + RL
Clip E8Joint RL + AMP

Brook trout

Window ti460 · 5 clips

Clip R2BLM + RL
Clip C7CPG + RL
Clip K3Joint RL
Clip Y5BCO + RL
Clip P7Joint RL + AMP

Brook trout

Window ti806 · 6 clips

Clip P3BLM + RL
Clip J8CPG + RL
Clip T6Joint RL
Clip U2BCO + RL
Clip M3Joint RL + AMP
Clip J6GLIDE · zero-action reference (attention check)

Catfish

Window ti1951 · 6 clips

Clip J4BLM + RL
Clip V7CPG + RL
Clip H5Joint RL
Clip V3BCO + RL
Clip X6Joint RL + AMP
Clip G7GLIDE · zero-action reference (attention check)

Catfish

Window ti1991 · 5 clips

Clip B5BLM + RL
Clip V2CPG + RL
Clip B7Joint RL
Clip R8BCO + RL
Clip A6Joint RL + AMP